When it comes to the best wings in South Jersey, two legendary names are always in the conversation — Pic-a-Lilli Inn in Shamong and The Jug Handle Inn in Cinnaminson.
Both are local icons, both have die-hard fans, and both have been serving wings long enough to perfect their craft. But which one truly deserves the crown? Let’s break it down.
Pic-a-Lilli Inn – The Classic Pine Barrens Favorite
Located along Route 206 in Shamong, Pic-a-Lilli Inn has been a South Jersey institution for decades. Known for its laid-back, rustic vibe and no-nonsense menu, Pic-a-Lilli has one main mission — serve up crispy, saucy perfection.
Why People Love Pic-a-Lilli Wings:
- Legendary Signature Sauce – Tangy, slightly sweet, with just the right amount of heat.
- Crispy Texture – Fried to perfection before being drenched in sauce.
- Generous Portion Sizes – You get big, meaty wings that satisfy even the hungriest appetite.
If you’re a traditional buffalo wing purist, Pic-a-Lilli delivers a nostalgic flavor that’s hard to beat.
The Jug Handle Inn – Variety and Bold Flavor
Over in Cinnaminson, The Jug Handle Inn has built its own empire of wing lovers. The sports bar atmosphere, friendly staff, and creative menu make it a go-to for anyone craving wings with a twist.
Why People Love Jug Handle Wings:
- Flavor Variety – Beyond buffalo, you’ll find garlic parmesan, mango habanero, spicy honey, and rotating specials.
- Grilled & Fried Options – A smoky char-grilled finish or a crispy fried bite — take your pick.
- Perfect with a Pint – The Jug is as much about the lively vibe as it is about the food.
If you’re the adventurous type, The Jug Handle Inn is where you can try something new every visit.
Head-to-Head: Sauce, Size, and Atmosphere
| Category | Pic-a-Lilli Inn | The Jug Handle Inn |
| Signature Sauce | Tangy, classic buffalo perfection | Dozens of flavors, creative combinations |
| Cooking Style | Fried crisp, sauce-drenched | Fried or grilled with smoky finish |
| Portion Size | Large, meaty wings | Slightly smaller, but more flavor options |
| Atmosphere | Cozy, Pine Barrens charm | High-energy sports bar vibe |
The SweetScenes Verdict
- For Classic Wing Lovers – Pic-a-Lilli Inn is your winner. The sauce alone is worth the drive.
- For Flavor Explorers – The Jug Handle Inn takes the crown. With so many unique options, it’s a wing lover’s playground.
Truth be told, South Jersey is lucky to have two heavyweight contenders. The real challenge? Not eating at both in the same week.
Plan Your Own Wing Tour
Why choose just one? Grab your friends and make a night of it:
- Start at Pic-a-Lilli Inn for the classic medium buffalo wings.
- Head to The Jug Handle Inn for a bold flavor you’ve never tried before.
- End the night with bragging rights and full stomachs.