When people in Merchantville, NJ talk about cheesesteaks, two names keep coming up—Merchantville Cheessteaks and Pinsetter Bar & Bowl’s Perfect Game. Both serve up mouthwatering takes on this local classic, and both have loyal fans ready to argue why their favorite is the best.
One is a dedicated cheesesteak shop serving big, juicy portions of shaved beef, melted cheese, and perfectly cooked onions on a fresh roll. The other comes from an unexpected spot—a bowling alley kitchen in nearby Pennsauken turning out a cheesesteak so good it demands to be part of the conversation.
The Contenders:
Merchantville Cheessteaks
- Packed with tender ribeye
- Generous cheese melt
- Soft sesame-seeded roll that soaks up the flavor
Pinsetter’s Perfect Game
- Premium shaved beef cooked to perfection
- Gooey melted cheese with just the right pull
- Toasted sesame-seeded roll with a satisfying crunch
Head-to-Head:
Flavor:
Merchantville Cheessteaks delivers bold, hearty flavor with every bite. Pinsetter’s Perfect Game is rich, balanced, and perfectly proportioned.
Texture:
Merchantville’s roll is soft and chewy, complementing the juicy beef. Pinsetter’s adds a light toasting for a crisp bite without losing tenderness.
Overall Experience:
Both hit the spot—Merchantville is a straight-to-the-point cheesesteak experience, while Pinsetter’s lets you pair your meal with drinks, games, and a lively atmosphere.
The Verdict:
It’s hard to call a clear winner, and maybe that’s the best part. Merchantville Cheessteaks nails the traditional approach, while Pinsetter’s Perfect Game brings a gourmet edge without straying too far from what makes a cheesesteak great.
The only way to decide? Try them both and see which one earns your vote for Best Cheesesteak in Merchantville, NJ.